Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main

Publication of a dissenting opinion does not justify setting aside an arbitral award

The Higher Regional Court Frankfurt/Main ruled in a decision published today that the publication of a dissenting opinion by an arbitrator regarding an arbitral award or its reasoning does not constitute a violation of the principle of ordre public and does not justify setting aside the arbitral award.

No. 60/2026

The parties to the proceedings closed a distribution agreement for dialysis machines in 2009. In 2018, the respondent terminated the agreement. The parties then initiated arbitration proceedings regarding their dispute over the validity of the termination and potential claims for damages and specific performance. In its October 2019 award, the arbitral tribunal dismissed the arbitration claim and, in response to the counterclaim, ordered the claimant to pay damages of approximately 1.25 million Euros. One of the three arbitrators issued a dissenting opinion on the arbitral award, in which he explained his differing view on certain issues addressed in the award. Arbitral award and dissenting opinion were submitted to the parties.

The claimant is seeking to have the arbitral award set aside. She claims that the arbitral court violated the principle of confidentiality of deliberations by publishing the dissenting opinion.

The 32nd Senate of the Higher Regional Court, which oversees arbitration proceedings, dismissed this motion. The Senate ruled that there were no grounds for setting aside the arbitral award. The Senate argued the arbitral award was not be set aside on the grounds that a dissenting opinion was issued and that it constitutes a violation of the principle of ordre public. The procedural principle of ordre public with respect to a domestic arbitral award is violated if the arbitral tribunal has disregarded a party’s fundamental procedural right and the arbitral award is based on that violation.

The admissibility of a dissenting opinion is not expressly regulated under German arbitration law. The principle of confidentiality of deliberations set out in the Judges Act applies to arbitrators as well. However, the Senate explained that a dissenting opinion issued by an arbitrator after the conclusion of the proceedings does not, in any event, violate the principle of confidentiality of deliberations to such an extent that “this disclosure, which occurs after deliberation and decision-making, would be manifestly incompatible with the fundamental principles of German law.” The Senate added that dissenting opinions are not entirely foreign to German law. A judge of the Federal Constitutional Court may, for example, set forth in a dissenting opinion the view he or she expressed during deliberations that differs from the decision or its reasoning. Another argument in favor of admissibility was that, regarding a dissenting opinion, the majority of the arbitrators were no longer entitled to protection at the time the dissenting opinion is announced. Furthermore, if a dissenting opinion were deemed inadmissible, the arbitrator whose opinion diverges from that of the majority would have considerable leverage if the mere submission of a dissenting opinion were sufficient to justify the annulment of an arbitral award. In addition, the Senate pointed out that the draft bill on the modernization of arbitration law expressly provides that a dissenting opinion regarding an arbitral award may be rendered as a separate opinion. It follows from the explanatory memorandum to the draft law that the legislature assumes that the submission of a dissenting opinion is already permissible at present and that, to that extent, the proposed statutory provision merely serves to clarify the matter.

The decision is subject to appeal.

Higher Regional Court Frankfurt/Main, decision of November 6, 2026, 32 Sch 3/26

Explanations

Generally, judges must maintain confidentiality regarding the deliberations and voting process. The principle of confidentiality of deliberations is part of judicial independence. It generally prohibits a judge from publicly expressing a dissenting opinion in a separate statement. A special provision applies to the Federal Constitutional Court, under which the publication of a dissenting opinion is permitted.

English version: deputy spokeswoman Dr. Kerstin Wierse

Schlagworte zum Thema